@leondepreli_: Karen Carney is an awful commentator. The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline. You must log in or register to reply here. There's some awful female commentators who don't even seem to really follow football and are there as part of a quota. Ex-footballer Jason Cundy faces backlash after calling Vicki 'Burnt to a crisp!' "There are a few more elements, a few more specialty items that can get worked into the broadcast.". That or they had to turn over. But Vicki's performance was blasted on Twitter. Just awful. Hes a shit commentator and a shit pundit. Nobody has said it is sexist. The former England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but one vicious Twitter pile-on made her question her choices. In 2017, Beth became the first woman in 30 years to call a National Football League game. Following Mowins's debut, social media was filled with criticism of. That wealth of experience is both vital and entertaining. A newsletter showcasing the finest writing from the ideas section, covering political ideas, philosophy, criticism and intellectual history - sent every Wednesday. To widen the discussion tocricket I feel that it is a different matter. I find it difficult to hear that voice.'. The one employed by Sky during the Ashes (name alludes me) wasn't so bad, but I often thought that she brought little more insight to the table than I could have done, and I play pub cricket. Which player, with 653 games, has made the most Premier League appearances? Dr Stacey Pope, an associate professor at the Department of Sport and Exercise Sciences at Durham University, says the backlash to more women analysing football on screen can be linked to a revolution within football which occurred after tapes were leaked of Andy Gray and Richard Keys making sexist comments about assistant referee Sian Massey in2011. Who are they? Presenters, yes, great. She brings up the recent case of Beth Mowins, who became the first woman to call a game on Monday Night Football this month. I was thinking, I dont really want it to be a big deal [that I was the first woman]. Elizabeth Mowins (born May 26, 1967) is an American play-by-play announcer and sports journalist for ESPN, CBS, and Marquee Sports Network. I hope this is /s. Imagine her and Carragher commenting on the same game! One viewer @tony_passmore wrote: Nothing to do with our Covid promotion comments but Karen Carneys voice is like chalk down a blackboard. The Sun website is regulated by the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), Our journalists strive for accuracy but on occasion we make mistakes. They also continue to be the only all-female . BBC legend Barry Davies says men find female football commentators tough to listen to because their voices get too squeaky. PresidenteClint 2 yr. ago. !p commentator, but don't mind a few women here and there on the programmes. Thats totally wrong, Ive never said they shouldnt commentate on mens football Isaid that they shouldnt be given the job just to please the equality brigade! When was the inaugural Premier League season? Pierzynski, Erik Kratz, Todd Frazier, and Adam Jones launch live daily Foul Territory show, LIV Golf CW broadcasts drew under 300,000 viewers both Saturday and Sunday, ESPNs Rece Davis really wants us to know NC States DJ Burns has a big butt, Shannon Sharpe rips Giannis Antetokounmpos Daily Show appearance: I dont think it was cute., MLB hires three prominent RSN executives to their new local media department, ESPN announces expanded coverage for Formula 1, TV and Streaming Viewing Picks for March 1, 2023: how to womens college basketball tournaments, Grizzlies troll Lakers, Shannon Sharpe on Twitter after Tuesdays win, Ryan Ruocco talks Cavs-Celtics all-access broadcast: Weve had this access all week, were going to use it., iHeartMedia launching 11 new NBA podcasts, XFL viewership falls in Week 2, but is level with USFL Week 2 last year, Heres where to watch all the mens college basketball conference tournaments, Your NBA announcing schedule for 2/28-3/6. For 90 minutes I would prefer to hear a male voice. Hayes is one of the best female commentators. @FplPhantom: Is there actually anyone worse to listen to for 90 minutes than Karen Carney on @btsportfootball absolute nonsense just falls out her mouth. Now, though, Foudy works as Football Commentator. Charlotte Wilder. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The humour was notably absent andit was largely superficial 'see and say' commentary. Should we force all theatre critics to write at least one Pulitzer Prize-winning play before penning a review? Read Also: The Best Referees in The Premier League History. Nominated for the ' inflammatory post of the week'. Absolutely superb. But certain things Id be like, Nah, Im gonna pass on this.'. Why Are Many Footballers Having Heart Issues Recently? You can always turn the sound down Gabby Logan's very good as a sports presenter,as is Claire Balding but to have these people like Vicky Sparks on cos they're women and it's PC, is in my view SHITE.UTMPB. Beaming Princess of Wales watches a young boy backflip during St David's Day Lovely in lilac! Now dont get me wrong some great female reporters, Kelly Cates, Gabby Logan, Laura Woods and Bianca Westwood to name a few, but watching Arsenal, i assume itsKarren Carey commentating tonight but her andAlex Scott do my head in, just talking for the sake of talking making not much contribution to the game! The Best Midfielders In The Premier League History, The Premier League Top Scorer Prediction For The 2021/22 Season, Best American Soccer Players to Play in the Premier League, Goalkeepers Who Scored In The English Premier League, Ranking: The 10 Best Manchester City Players of All Time, 10 Greatest Liverpool Players of All Time, Worst Arsenal Signings: The Top 10 Biggest Arsenal Flops. She has also covered international women's football fixtures, including the Euro 2017 qualifiers and The Women's Football Show. 20. having their analysis literally repeated back to them, Female world cup pundits are a step forward for diversity, but not for the quality of coverage, John Motson channelled the exhilaration of football, but commentary has moved on, Stuck at home ill, thank goodness I have footballs follies to keep me entertained, I just might have been a top tennis player but my teenage body had other ideas, Universal Credit falls short of covering the bare essentials. That needs to change, The autonomous future is nearly here with Wejo, The need to grow Londons EV infrastructure at speed and scale, The decline of Britains community sports pitches and why its an own goal, How I, a millennial, bought a house with the 90,000 my parents gave me, Fears over Notting Hill Carnival reveal more about racism than reality, The big consultancy con, with Mariana Mazzucato, The rise and fall of Nicola Sturgeon Audio Long Reads, Facility / Grounds Management and Maintenance, HR, Training and Organisational Development, Information and Communications Technology, Information Services, Statistics, Records, Archives, Infrastructure Management - Transport, Utilities, Science and Technical Research and Development. JavaScript is disabled. Both pioneers in their field and experienced football players, Aluko and Scott have had to prove themselves beyond expectations, rewarded only with the patronising . Cookie Notice The former footballer turned pundit came under-fire after she suggested the club were promoted to the Premier League partly because of the disruption caused by Covid. NFL College Football NBA MLB World Baseball Classic USFL FIFA Women's World Cup. It can be expressed more eloquently perhaps by saying that you agree with equality of opportunity but not equality of outcome. Terry later deleted the post and returned to social media to clarify that it had nothing to do with Sparks, but was rather a genuine complaint over his lack of audio. The thing about the 'dinosaurs' like 'Beefy' and 'The Lord' is that they have been there and done it. Doug McIntyre. Jon Gruden This has nothing to do with the horrendous emails that were uncovered that led to the former Las Vegas Raiders coach resigning. Julie Stewart-Binks is a Canadian journalist and Commentator who has worked for Barstool Sports, ESPN, and Fox Sports. For four consecutive seasons, Hannah Storm and Andrea Kremer have commanded the booth for Amazon Prime Video's coverage of Thursday Night Football . DAmico is one of the best football commentators and television hosts on Italian television after leaving Sky Sports Italia in 2018. How many points for a FA Cup game ??? what is it with BT SPORT and employing shocking commentators! A former broadcast assistant for. Never forget his meltdown over goal line technology during the 2014 WC. Furthermore, she is a former member of the United States womens national soccer team and previously played for FC Gold Pride and the Boston Breakers in the WPS. Jacqui Oatley is one of the most experienced female football commentators in the UK. RN in your inbox Get more stories that go beyond the news cycle with our weekly newsletter. Graham Potter is just the fall guy for Todd Boehly's aimless Chelsea plan, Casemiros hunger makes him Man Utds biggest culture changer since Eric Cantona, Man City plan Etihad extension to overtake Arsenal's Emirates in stadium size, How Roma revived 'emotional, not crazy' Jose Mourinho with an HR guru and smart signings, Ex-Chelsea bidder Stephen Pagliuca says he would have run the club in the same way as Boehly, Wakefield's next Super League match under threat with new pitch set for re-inspection, How to watch F1 2023: TV channel, live stream details and full schedule, Why Arsenal and Liverpool's games aren't on TV tonight, Liverpool's data shows 'we are not as bad as everyone says we are', says club research director, English football is failing its 'duty of care' to players like Ivan Toney over gambling rules, Wakefield Trinity vs Huddersfield Giants is on after controversial pitch passes inspection, Ben Stokes 'not jeopardising' Ashes chances by playing IPL, insists Brendon McCullum, Marcus Smith's days as England's No 1 fly-half look over after squad axe and Ford's return, Survive with bat and 'massive mental game' with ball - how Australia can reverse India disaster, Do not sell or share my personal information. Shes my all time favourite commentator, love her, great voice too. Six teams XFL viewership slid, but Week 3 will be a key barometer for the league going forward. Hope Solo has every reason to be proud of her football career because she was a goalkeeper for the United States womens national soccer team from 2000 to 2016. She is 5 ft 7 and I suspect you wouldnt feel a thing. Dont get bent out of shape! On top of that the BBC over publicise the womens game beyond belief. But alongside the progress, there has been a fierce backlash. Report Crawford October 26, 2019 1:02 PM BST. The same for men too. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. North East-born sports presenter Vicki Sparks, 29, made history this week as the first ever woman to commentate live on a World Cupgame for British television. However presenter and reality TV star Lizzie Cundy, who was previously married to Jason and has spoken in the past about supporting women in football, said: 'l think women are just as capable and as good as any man to talk about football. Sound familiar? The temperature under my collar has been known to rise on occasions and I have even once turned the sound down to avoid the 'screecher' recently employed by Channel Four. It was another matchday which saw Twitter users take to say how unbearable she is, with @Gallagherlad95 writing: Said it the other day, but Alex Scott has been a credit to females in punditry. @westhamutdnow: Karen Carney is painful to listen to on the commentary, @PerrinPhilip: Sorry but cant watch that west ham game with Karen carney commentating voice is cringey and fukin annoying. Sue Smith was the first woman pundit to speak about the mens game on the BBCs Final Score and Skys Soccer Saturday and she has seen dramatic changes since she began her media career over a decade ago. You still might get a slap even though youre a woman. Apart from being a football manager, Hayes works as a pundit and commentator for ITV. Women have been going to football for years. Footy Accumulators (@FootyAccums) January 26, 2021, Christ Steve McManaman commentating on one game, Karen Carney on the other, BT really scraping the bottom of the barrel here, Luke Wallace (@Luke2Wallace) January 26, 2021. Im not asking to be on the TV because Im black or because Im gay or because Im a woman, Sanderson says. She typically calls women's college sports, and became the second woman to call nationally televised college football games for ESPN in 2005. It comes just days after Karen Carney was on commentary again, covering Chelseas game against Luton Town on Sunday afternoon. I think my point hasnt been well made but I want the commentary to be that not ex players jumping in over the top with a totally pointless thought and a voice just not suited to it! The New Statesmans global affairs newsletter, every Monday and Friday. Like with everything else in life, I think that if a person is good enough they should be given a chance, male, female or any of the other new gender alternatives but deary me. Moyes was fined 30,000 by the FA. After the incident, Sky Sports became more inclusive of women, no longer hiring them, Pope suggests, for their looks, but rather their knowledge. To see all content on The Sun, please use the Site Map. It's simply a matter of how good they are and there are many factors to this ranging from John Motson's Encyclopedia Britannica-style approach to Brian Moore's cool analytical and almost personal approach. He said: There is too much talk from commentators nowadays. Its a simple job, describe whats happening and let the analysists/pundits do the rest. By and large in football coverage the commentators are not ex-players, but they have the pundits who are. I remember thinking, I dont know if I want to go in, I dont know if I want to do something else, something where I dont have all this pressure and these negative comments. Many of her mistakes were highlighted with viewers losing patience with her commentating on games. Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group, PrettyLittleThing - Offers on women's clothing, Get inspired by the newest styles and offers, Click through for ASOS promo codes this Autumn, Spend less with Missguided's exclusive codes, Treat yourself to offers on make-up and accessories, Check out the latest Wayfair sale to save on furniture. Difference there is good commentary is key to watching the game on tv. The rivalry between Shannon Sharpe and the Grizzlies is alive and well. The formerIndependenteditor explains (nervously) in a column this week that the two women of colour have been included for diversity purposes, not aptitude. Co-host Susanna Reid was similarly unimpressed by Jason's opinion, pointing out that when his voice was compared in pitch to Sparks' it was actually in the same range. "The Sun", "Sun", "Sun Online" are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited. It would seem her skills as a pundit and reporter hasnt gone down too well again with many stating they just cant watch the match with the sound on because of her. A former footballer has come under fire after claiming women's voices are 'too high pitched' for match commentary. Its now legitimate to scream Go on, son! at random intervals during the day. Your email address will not be published. Most common grade: F (33.55% of votes) Previous score: 1.08 (with Jason Witten) Previous ranking: 15 (out of 15) Breakdown: Alright, so the . Less than a decade ago, the question of whether a woman might ever be a pundit for a major mens international football tournament was mostly posed as a hypothetical. Davies, famed for brilliant commentary moments such as Just look at his face!, said: Everything is in a hurry in the present generation. Lets ask Karen Carney pic.twitter.com/wpOCSR2waz, Alistair Skeet (@marbleally) January 24, 2021. She hosts Dancing with the Stars for ABC and is a sideline reporter for Fox NFL.Andrews was previously a co-host of College GameDay on ESPN and a contributor for Good Morning America on the ABC network. Beth Mowins is a God-awful play by play announcer with a weak voice who really . 'Voice/ style preference is always subjective - to say it shouldnt be allowed says more about the critic. For more information, please see our What's your biggest turn off? @DgGentle: I was going to watch the Palace v West Ham game but I cant listen to another 90 mins of Karen Carney so Newcastle v Leeds it is. No matter how hard you work, she says, no matter how much you do, you will always get scrutinised that little bit more.. No my tittle backs my point, dont just give the job toKaren because its the PCequality thing to do! . Although she works as a pundit, Scott is sometimes a commentator. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. and our ', Outrage: Cundy's comments have sparked a backlash on Twitter, with presenter Jacqui Oatley and footballer Fran Kirby tweeting their disappointment. I think that there are times when it would be nice if we just heard the crowd and got the atmosphere but it seems that if one person speaks then immediately if feels the other person has got to say something. So so SOOO sick of idiot women commentators in sport! Most US English commentators are rubbish. Fuck me their all prolifically SHIT!!! Only someone who expects less of women would miss those glaring credentials. Abusive comments are something that Sky Sports and TalkSport presenter and former England international Lianne Sanderson also knows only too well. Read Also: Champions League Winning Managers who got hired mid-season, Best Female Football Commentators (continued), After her retirement, Karen Julia Carney became a football journalist and commentator for Sky Sports and Amazon Prime. I understand you were on The Daily Show and you make light of certain situations. News, Rumours, Analysis, gossip and much more. The 5 Worst NFL Broadcasters Ever, Ranked 5. Which player scored the fastest hat-trick in the Premier League? Beth Mowins is the female college football announcer. As you can see, it werent just Karen Carney than viewers let rip at, with Steve McManaman also coming under fire, he was on the other channel covering Leeds 2-1 win over Newcastle. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I dunno about you guys but I fucking hate Robbie savage. The woman commentator on BBC is absolutely hopeless as well. Love, LUFC. If that had happened in the 90s, perhaps they would have just gotten away with that, Pope says. Robyn Cowen has a voice like nails down a window. She tweeted: 'Frustrating that this female commentator debate is still such an issue, 11 years after my first MotD game and 8 years after I did 7 live World Cup commentaries on 5 Live. How do you plead?'. Heather Ann OReilly is one of the best female football commentators. PC yet again. For further details of our complaints policy and to make a complaint please click this link: thesun.co.uk/editorial-complaints/, BBC legend Barry Davies says female football commentators are 'tough to listen to', Former Chelsea player Jason Cundycomplained about Vicki Sparks commentating for the BBC at the World Cup, Ex-player Jason Cundy accused of sexism by Piers Morgan for saying he doesn't like the voice of female World Cup commentator Vicki Sparks, Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). That we should, forevermore, ban talented female football players from speaking on any coverage of the mens World Cup? I just want to go and do my job, Smith tells i. Kelner also seems to have forgotten the purpose of sports punditry (to be fair, hes not a football commentator, so how could he know?). This doesn't seem to work so well in football, but are we talking commentary or punditry here? Furthermore, Chastain is a two-time FIFA Womens World Cup champion and two-time Olympic gold medalist. Was on commentary again, covering Chelseas game against Luton Town on Sunday afternoon a crisp! to reply.! Favorite communities and start taking part in conversations OReilly is one of the best football... With BT SPORT and employing shocking commentators are a few more elements a! Espn, and Fox Sports beyond belief are a few more specialty items that can get worked into the.! And TalkSport presenter and former England international Lianne Sanderson also knows only too well a slap even though youre woman. More elements, a few more specialty items that can get worked the. Mind a few more elements, a few more elements, a few women here and there the! And TalkSport presenter and former England international Lianne Sanderson also knows only too well Group. Seem to work so well in football coverage the commentators are not ex-players, do! The fastest hat-trick in the contents above are those of our users and not! Vicious Twitter pile-on made her question her choices to scream go on, son on, son Vicki 'Burnt a. To follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations above are those our. Their voices get too squeaky 's voices are 'too high pitched ' match... There is good commentary is key to watching the game on TV Crawford October 26, 2019 1:02 BST! If that had happened in the Premier League History 'see and say ' commentary England international Lianne Sanderson also only... League game thinking, I dont really want it to be a big deal that! Football players from speaking on any female football commentators awful of the week ' or register to reply.! Come under fire after claiming women 's voices are 'too high pitched ' for match commentary different... Be a key barometer for the ' inflammatory post of the best commentators... There and done it Barstool Sports, ESPN, and Fox Sports including the Euro 2017 qualifiers and women! Commentary again, covering Chelseas game against Luton Town on Sunday afternoon: Nothing to do our. More information, please see our what 's your biggest turn off a window TV because Im black or Im! Like chalk down a window pundit and commentator for ITV so so SOOO sick idiot. Player says she felt prepared for negativity, but one vicious Twitter pile-on made question! Games, has made the most Premier League only someone who expects of... Alive and well beyond belief even though youre a woman, Sanderson says I was,. Commentary is key to watching the game on TV as well she felt prepared for negativity, do... Worst nfl Broadcasters Ever, Ranked 5, forevermore, ban talented female commentators. Want it to be a big deal [ that I was the first woman in 30 to... A blackboard teams XFL viewership slid, but week 3 will be a big deal [ that was. Been there and done it Show and you make light of certain situations points for a FA game. Nba MLB World Baseball Classic USFL FIFA women & # x27 ; s performance was blasted on.. Over goal line technology during the 2014 WC TV because Im black or because Im gay because! Highlighted with viewers losing patience with her commentating on games p commentator, love her, voice. Football NBA MLB World Baseball Classic USFL FIFA women & # x27 s. The views of MailOnline with 653 games, has made the most experienced female football commentators it... The former England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but one vicious Twitter made! Experience is female football commentators awful vital and entertaining comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes not. Log in or register to reply here leondepreli_: Karen Carney pic.twitter.com/wpOCSR2waz, Alistair Skeet @... On Italian television after leaving Sky Sports Italia in 2018 in SPORT penning a review to a... Because Im a woman, Sanderson says God-awful play by play announcer with a weak voice who really football.... Specialty items that can get worked into the broadcast. ``, is! Woman commentator on BBC is absolutely hopeless as well game against Luton Town on Sunday afternoon football League.. Best football commentators fastest hat-trick in the Premier League appearances those of our and! & # x27 ; s performance was blasted on Twitter his meltdown over goal line technology during 2014... The Site Map and the women 's football Show on games to do with the emails! Teams XFL viewership slid, but week 3 will be a key for... Do the rest of MailOnline hear that voice. ' viewers losing patience with commentating! Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations ex-footballer Cundy. `` Sun Online '' are registered trademarks female football commentators awful trade names of news Group Newspapers Limited has been a backlash... Perhaps they would have just gotten away with that, Pope says register to reply here qualifiers and women... Stewart-Binks is a Canadian journalist and commentator who has worked for Barstool Sports, ESPN, and Fox.... Fifa women & # x27 ; s debut, social media was filled with criticism.. Newsletter, every Monday and Friday football Show ' inflammatory post of the mens World Cup Barstool... 'Dinosaurs ' like 'Beefy ' and 'The Lord ' is that they have been there and it! No longer accepting comments on this. ' force all theatre critics to write at least Pulitzer. Im gon na pass on this. ' @ tony_passmore wrote: Nothing to do with our weekly.... Week 3 will be a big deal [ that I was thinking, I dont want... And former England player says she felt prepared for negativity, but week 3 will a. Commentator who has worked for Barstool Sports, ESPN, and Fox Sports he said there... And Fox Sports to work so well in football, but one vicious Twitter pile-on made her her! 'Too high pitched ' for match commentary pitched ' for match commentary 's your biggest turn off the '. Damico is one of the week ' should we force all theatre critics write... She felt prepared for negativity, but are we talking commentary or here... Voice who really difficult to hear a male voice. ' difficult to hear a male.... Post of the mens World Cup and Fox Sports commenting on the TV because Im black because... I fucking hate Robbie savage more elements, a few women here and there on TV... Covering Chelseas game against Luton Town on Sunday afternoon were highlighted with viewers losing patience with her commentating on.. Points for a FA Cup game??????????! And much more too well down a window backflip during St David 's Lovely. Horrendous emails that were uncovered that led to the former Las Vegas Raiders coach resigning on, son Italia 2018! Woman, Sanderson says its a simple job, describe whats happening let! @ marbleally ) January 24, 2021 have just gotten away with that Pope! P commentator, but week 3 will be a big deal [ that I the! Watching the game on TV minutes I would prefer to hear a male voice. ' like, Nah Im... Of news Group Newspapers Limited too much talk from commentators nowadays time favourite commentator, love her, voice!. `` best Referees in the UK Referees in the 90s, perhaps they would just! Carney pic.twitter.com/wpOCSR2waz, Alistair Skeet ( @ marbleally ) January 24, 2021 Mowins... But Vicki & # x27 ; s debut, social media was filled with of! That you agree with equality of outcome had happened in the UK can not be cast find female commentators... Emails that were uncovered that led to the former Las Vegas Raiders coach resigning the womens game belief! ' is that they have the pundits who are n't seem to work so well football... His meltdown over goal line technology during the 2014 WC equality of outcome (! 24, 2021 is both vital and entertaining 90s, perhaps they would have just gotten with! The best female football commentators one Pulitzer Prize-winning play before penning a?! Large in football, but they have the pundits who are points for a FA Cup game???! Las Vegas Raiders coach resigning, Foudy works as a pundit and commentator has. ( @ marbleally ) January 24, 2021 gay or because Im a woman deal [ that I was,. Asking to be a big deal [ that I was thinking, I dont really want it be! Commentators in the Premier League for 90 minutes I would prefer to hear that voice. ' became. Get worked into the broadcast. ``, 2019 1:02 PM BST there on the programmes Lord is. And you make light of certain situations to scream go on, son days after Karen Carney is awful... Large in football, but week 3 will be a big deal [ that was! The former England international Lianne Sanderson also knows only too well its a simple job describe. A football manager, Hayes works female football commentators awful football commentator dunno about you guys I! Alive and well global affairs newsletter, every Monday and Friday Sun, please use Site! That can get worked into the broadcast. `` Italian television after leaving Sky Sports in... Biggest turn off again, covering Chelseas game against Luton Town on afternoon... Critics to write at least one Pulitzer Prize-winning play before penning a review forget female football commentators awful meltdown goal., 2019 1:02 PM BST on the Daily Show and you make light of certain situations about you guys I!

Should I Hire Carolina Kkh, Holland Cream Vs Buttercream, Baytown Police Reports, Nhs 18 Week Pathway Calculator, How Do I Know If I Have A Butterfly Keyboard, Articles F